Quick answer: Fratelli’s Pizza is an independent local business in Flagstaff, Arizona, at 2120 North 4th Street, listed under Casual & Comfort. Phone: +1 928-714-9700.
Fratelli's Pizza is a locally established Flagstaff pizzeria with an East Side location on North Fourth Street. Founded by Peter and Brent Schepper in 2002, the restaurant makes its dough in house, proofs and hand tosses each crust, then bakes pizzas in a stone deck oven. The kitchen prepares its own tomato sauce using tomatoes from Stanislaus County, California, and shreds whole milk mozzarella on site. Vegan mozzarella is also available for dairy free diners. Customers can order pizza for pickup or delivery, and the company operates additional locations in downtown Flagstaff and Fort Valley. Fratelli's also supports local schools, youth organizations, nonprofits, fundraising programs, field trips, blood drives, and other community efforts throughout the Flagstaff area.
Highlights
- Stone deck oven pizza
- Housemade hand tossed dough
- Mozzarella shredded in house
- Vegan cheese available
- Three Flagstaff locations
What Fratelli’s Pizza offers
- Stone baked pizza
- Pizza by the slice
- Pickup orders
- Delivery
- Vegan mozzarella
- Mozzarella sticks
- Fundraising programs
- School field trips
In the news
- Best Italian Restaurants in Flagstaff, Discover Flagstaff (2026). This local dining guide highlights Fratelli's specialty pizzas, longstanding Best of Flagstaff recognition and family meal offering.
- Pizza Delivery By Electric Cargo Bike (In My Town)!, Electric Bike Report (2011). The trade publication reports on Fratelli's addition of an electric cargo bicycle to its Flagstaff pizza delivery fleet.
- Out West Food Review: Fratelli Pizza, Out West Food Review (2008). This restaurant feature discusses Fratelli's large New York style slices, homemade dough, calzones and casual family atmosphere.
What reviewers mention
Reviewers commonly praise the thin crust pizzas, varied specialty toppings, salads and casual atmosphere, although experiences with counter service, order accuracy and value are sometimes inconsistent.
Details
- Address: 2120 North 4th Street, Flagstaff, AZ
- Phone: +1 928-714-9700
- Website: fratellipizza.net
- Category: Casual & Comfort
More Casual & Comfort in Flagstaff
Frequently asked questions
Where is Fratelli’s Pizza located?
Fratelli’s Pizza is located at 2120 North 4th Street, Flagstaff, AZ.
What is the phone number for Fratelli’s Pizza?
You can reach Fratelli’s Pizza at +1 928-714-9700.
What kind of business is Fratelli’s Pizza?
Fratelli’s Pizza is listed under Casual & Comfort in the Northern Arizona Co. directory for Flagstaff.
What does Fratelli’s Pizza offer?
Fratelli’s Pizza offers Stone baked pizza, Pizza by the slice, Pickup orders, Delivery, Vegan mozzarella and Mozzarella sticks.
When was Fratelli’s Pizza founded?
Fratelli’s Pizza was founded in 2002.
Who owns Fratelli’s Pizza?
Fratelli’s Pizza is owned or was founded by Peter Schepper and Brent Schepper.
Is Fratelli’s Pizza locally owned?
Fratelli’s Pizza is listed as an independent local business, not a national chain.
Does Fratelli’s Pizza have a website?
Yes. The website for Fratelli’s Pizza is fratellipizza.net.
Listing last checked November 2026. Details can change, so confirm with the business.
Browse: Local Fine Dining · Casual & Comfort · Everything in Flagstaff
Is this your business? Listings are free, and owners will be able to claim and update their page soon.