Quick answer: Fratelli’s Pizza Downtown is an independent local business in Flagstaff, Arizona, at 119 West Phoenix Avenue, listed under Casual & Comfort. Phone: +1-928-714-9700.
Fratelli's Pizza Downtown is a locally founded pizzeria at West Phoenix Avenue in Flagstaff. The downtown location serves pizzas made from dough prepared in house, proofed, hand tossed, topped, and baked in a stone deck oven. Its sauce uses California tomatoes, while whole milk mozzarella is shredded in the restaurant. Dairy free diners can request vegan mozzarella as an alternative. Pickup and delivery ordering are available, and the brand also operates East Side and Fort Valley locations in Flagstaff. Brothers Peter and Brent Schepper opened Fratelli Pizza in 2002 and moved the original downtown operation to its current address in 2007. Beyond food service, the company supports area schools, youth organizations, educational programs, local nonprofits, fundraising activities, and blood drives.
Highlights
- Stone deck oven pizza
- Dough made and tossed in house
- Downtown Flagstaff since 2007
- Vegan mozzarella available
- Locally founded in 2002
What Fratelli’s Pizza Downtown offers
- Stone baked pizza
- Hand tossed pizza
- Pizza pickup
- Pizza delivery
- Vegan mozzarella option
- Fundraising programs
- School field trips
In the news
- Fratelli Pizza becomes a Flagstaff, Arizona, staple, Pizza Today (2014). This trade publication feature traces the brothers' growth from a tiny downtown shop into a successful, community-focused Flagstaff pizzeria.
- Best Italian Restaurants in Flagstaff, Discover Flagstaff (2026). This local travel guide highlights Fratelli's award-winning pizza and recommends its sweet and spicy Diavola pie.
Recognition
- Best of Flagstaff (2002)
What reviewers mention
Reviewers commonly praise the crisp hand-tossed pizza, varied toppings, gluten-free choices, friendly staff and casual local atmosphere, though experiences with counter service and wait times vary.
Details
- Address: 119 West Phoenix Avenue, Flagstaff, AZ 86001
- Phone: +1-928-714-9700
- Website: fratellipizza.net
- Category: Casual & Comfort
More Casual & Comfort in Flagstaff
Frequently asked questions
Where is Fratelli’s Pizza Downtown located?
Fratelli’s Pizza Downtown is located at 119 West Phoenix Avenue, Flagstaff, AZ 86001.
What is the phone number for Fratelli’s Pizza Downtown?
You can reach Fratelli’s Pizza Downtown at +1-928-714-9700.
What kind of business is Fratelli’s Pizza Downtown?
Fratelli’s Pizza Downtown is listed under Casual & Comfort in the Northern Arizona Co. directory for Flagstaff.
What does Fratelli’s Pizza Downtown offer?
Fratelli’s Pizza Downtown offers Stone baked pizza, Hand tossed pizza, Pizza pickup, Pizza delivery, Vegan mozzarella option and Fundraising programs.
When was Fratelli’s Pizza Downtown founded?
Fratelli’s Pizza Downtown was founded in 2002.
Who owns Fratelli’s Pizza Downtown?
Fratelli’s Pizza Downtown is owned or was founded by Peter Schepper and Brent Schepper.
Is Fratelli’s Pizza Downtown locally owned?
Fratelli’s Pizza Downtown is listed as an independent local business, not a national chain.
Does Fratelli’s Pizza Downtown have a website?
Yes. The website for Fratelli’s Pizza Downtown is fratellipizza.net.
Listing last checked November 2026. Details can change, so confirm with the business.
Browse: Local Fine Dining · Casual & Comfort · Everything in Flagstaff
Is this your business? Listings are free, and owners will be able to claim and update their page soon.